Market overview
Allowed, with material limits.
Fire Island is split among the Towns of Babylon, Islip and Brookhaven and the Villages of Ocean Beach and Saltaire, each with its own rules.
Property eligibility: Not assessed A market overview can't tell whether a specific home qualifies (zoning, permits, HOA).
Work for Fire Island? Claim this page to confirm or correct the rules.
17 rules on record for Fire Island, 11 of them from government sources. Every rule traced to its official source. How we research
Free account includes full rules for one place, with change alerts. Full report $39 · See a sample. For a lender or insurer: rules summary for one address, $29, free with the report. Already have an account? Sign in.
Source: villageofoceanbeach.org (official), checked 7 Nov 2026. Official links, citations and how to apply come with a paid plan.
Yes, with material limits. Fire Island is split among the Towns of Babylon, Islip and Brookhaven and the Villages of Ocean Beach and Saltaire, each with its own rules.
14.25% in total on stays, on our records.
Fines of up to $3,000 are on record.
We last checked the short-term rental rules for Fire Island on 7 Nov 2026.
LawfulStay tracks short-term rental rules for 5,120+ places, with every rule traced to its official source.
Search the database →